Paperback / softback
August 9, 2001
9.00 Inches (US)
6.00 Inches (US)
.75 Pounds (US)
$29.95 USD, £22.50 GBP
v2.1 Reference

Women in Combat

Civic Duty or Military Liability?

Women have been actively involved the United States military for more than fifty years, but the ban on their participation in combat remains a hotly debated issue. In this provocative book Lorry M. Fenner, an active-duty Air Force intelligence officer, calls for opening all aspects of military service to women. Marie deYoung, a former Army chaplain, argues that keeping women out of combat is in the best interests of both sexes and crucial to the effectiveness of the military as a whole.

Fenner bases her argument for inclusion of women on the idea that democracies require all citizens to compete in public endeavor and share in civic obligation. She contends that, historically, reasons for banning women from combat have been culturally biased. She argues that membership in a combat force should be based on capability judged against appropriate standards. Moreover, she maintains that excluding women hampers the diversity and adaptability that by necessity will characterize the armed forces in the twenty-first century.

In contrast, deYoung declares that the different physical fitness standards for men and women would, in combat, lower morale for both sexes and put women at risk of casualty. Further, she contends that women have neither the physical or emotional strength to endure the overall brutality of the combat experience. She also asserts that calls for lifting the combat ban are politically motivated and are inconsistent with the principles of American democracy and the mission of national defense.

With each author responding to the views of the other, their exchange offers a valuable synthesis of the issues surrounding a longstanding debate among policymakers, military personnel, and scholars of both military history and women's studies.

About the Authors

Lorry M. Fenner is a colonel (select) in the U.S. Air Force and the deputy commander of the 694th Intelligence Group.

Marie deYoung, the director of the Newman Catholic Center at Northeast Missouri State University, has served as a chaplain in the U.S. Army. The author of This Woman's Army: The Dynamics of Sex and Violence in the Military (Hellgate Press, 2000), she is currently researching issues surrounding education and the military.


"The book provides an exhaustive debate on both sides of this argument and asks hard questions on everything from lowering military physical fitness standards to the psychological impact of women killed or hurt in combat. ... Read this excellent volume and draw your own conclusions."—Terrorism and Political Violence


"Both positions are presented with a moral intensity and an intellectual force that makes Women in Combat a model for disputations on public issues."—Dennis Showalter, Colorado College

"Informed and passionate, Lieutenant Colonel Fenner and Captain deYoung argue opposing views, forcing the attentive reader to confront the tough question: If women are vital to the American military, why exclude them from combat?"—John Shy, professor emeritus of history, University of Michigan

"Women in Combat offers an impassioned and stimulating debate significant to all of us."—Gerald F. Linderman, professor emeritus of history, University of Michigan

"This is an extremely thoughtful as well as thought-provoking presentation of contrasting views on a subject of critical importance to the future of the United States defense policy. It is certain to provoke both reflection and controversy."—Gerhard L. Weinberg, emeritus, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill

Georgetown University Press
Controversies in Public Policy

9780878408634 : women-in-combat-fenner-deyoung
Paperback / softback
192 Pages
$29.95 USD

Other Titles from Controversies in Public Policy

Who Pays for Car Accidents?

Estate of Jerry J. Phillips, Stephen Chippendale
Dec 2001 - Georgetown University Press
$21.95 USD - Paperback / softback

Does Family Preservation Serve a Child's Best Interests?

Howard Altstein, Ruth G. McRoy
Aug 2000 - Georgetown University Press
$29.95 USD - Paperback / softback

The Privatization of Policing

Brian Forst, Peter K. Manning
May 1999 - Georgetown University Press
$29.95 USD - Paperback / softback
$29.95 USD - Electronic book text

Other Titles in POLITICAL SCIENCE / Public Policy / General

Patient Safety Ethics

John D. Banja
Jun 2019 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$49.95 USD - Hardback
$49.95 USD - Electronic book text

Governing Health, fifth edition

William G. Weissert and Carol S. Weissert
Apr 2019 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$84.95 USD - Hardback
$44.95 USD - Paperback / softback
$44.95 USD - Electronic book text

Life and Death in Rikers Island

Homer Venters, former Chief Medical Officer of NYC Jails
Feb 2019 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$26.95 USD - Paperback / softback
$26.95 USD - Electronic book text

Other Titles in Politics & government

Black Power, updated edition

Jeffrey O. G. Ogbar - with a new preface
Mar 2019 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$32.95 USD - Paperback / softback

Containing Contagion

Sara E. Davies
Mar 2019 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$54.95 USD - Paperback / softback
$54.95 USD - Electronic book text

The Age of Strict Construction

Zavodnyik Peter , Peter Zavodnyik
Aug 2018 - The Catholic University of America Press
$34.95 USD - Paperback / softback