November 1, 2001
9.75 Inches (US)
6.50 Inches (US)
1.15 Pounds (US)
$39.99 USD
v2.1 Reference


Sophist and Artist

Of the ancient Greek Sophists, Gorgias of Leontini (ca. 483–ca. 376 b.c.e.) has endured more than his share of insistent detractors. Aristophanes depicted him as a barbaric sycophant, Plato considered him an opportunistic charlatan indifferent to truth and morality, and Aristotle saw him as a gaudy but inept stylist.

Scott Consigny joins the commentators who find merit in Gorgias's thought, but his perceptions of Gorgias differ from those of the two most influential efforts at rehabilitation. He maintains that both the "subjectivist" reading by Hegel and the "empiricist" reading by George Grote—and among the rhetoricians of today by Richard Enos and Edward Schiappa—grant too much to Plato and Aristotle at the same time that, like most current interpretations of Gorgias, they fail to take into account all the extant remarks by the Sophist. By viewing Gorgias as in more radical disagreement with Plato and Aristotle than the other rehabilitators do, Consigny brings order to the Sophist's elusive, enigmatic ideas and peculiar style and stations him as a seminal philosopher and skilled artist, a formidable rival to Plato and Parmenides.

On Consigny's reading, Gorgias is an antifoundationalist who repudiates the idea that knowledge and truth must be grounded in objective standards or in subjective certainty but instead views truth as a category that a community employs to endorse what it finds persuasive. Consigny's reading is one development of Stanley Fish's assertion that "modern antifoundationalism is old Sophism writ analytic," and he pursues his insight into Gorgias's moral and political philosophy, where he sees antifoundationalism manifesting itself in a conventionalist ethic and the advocacy of a peaceful competition among different societies. In Gorgias's notorious style Consigny detects a playful mocking of the genres in which his contemporaries worked but the serious underscoring of the rhetoricity of all texts.

About the Author

Scott Consigny is an associate professor of English at Iowa State University in Ames. The author of numerous articles on rhetorical and literary theory, he has published in Philosophy and Rhetoric, Rhetoric Review, and the Rhetorical Society Quarterly, among other journals in the field.

9781570034244 : gorgias-consigny
242 Pages
$39.99 USD

Other Titles from Studies in Rhetoric/Communication

On Fire

edited by Sean Patrick O'Rourke
Feb 2021 - University of South Carolina Press
$19.99 USD - Paperback / softback
$14.99 USD - Electronic book text

Rhetoric of the Chinese Cultural Revolution

Xing Lu
Aug 2020 - University of South Carolina Press
$51.99 USD - Hardback
$29.99 USD - Paperback / softback
$29.99 USD - Electronic book text

Like Wildfire

edited by Sean Patrick O'Rourke, Lesli K. Pace
Jun 2020 - University of South Carolina Press
$49.99 USD - Hardback
$49.99 USD - Electronic book text

Other Titles in PHILOSOPHY / General

Tennis and Philosophy

edited by David Baggett, with contributions by David Baggett, David F. Wallace, David Baggett, Mark Huston, Kevin Kinghorn, Kevin Kinghorn, David Detmer, Tommy Valentini, Robert R. Clewis, Mark Foreman, Helen Ditouras, Mark Huston, Jean...
May 2021 - University Press of Kentucky
$45.00 USD - Hardback
$45.00 USD - Electronic book text

The Philosophy of TV Noir

Steven Sanders, Aeon J. Skoble
Mar 2021 - University Press of Kentucky
$45.00 USD - Hardback
$45.00 USD - Electronic book text

Knowing the Natural Law

Steven Jensen
Feb 2020 - The Catholic University of America Press
$34.95 USD - Paperback / softback