Hardback
May 31, 2007
9780253348739
English
360
9.25 Inches (US)
6.13 Inches (US)
1.5 Pounds (US)
$32.00 USD, £25.00 GBP
v2.1 Reference

Antisemitism, Christian Ambivalence, and the Holocaust

Edited by Kevin P. Spicer
In recent years, the mask of tolerant, secular, multicultural Europe has been shattered by new forms of antisemitic crime. Though many of the perpetrators do not profess Christianity, antisemitism has flourished in Christian Europe. In this book, thirteen scholars of European history, Jewish studies, and Christian theology examine antisemitism's insidious role in Europe's intellectual and political life. The essays reveal that annihilative antisemitic thought was not limited to Germany, but could be found in the theology and liturgical practice of most of Europe's Christian churches. They dismantle the claim of a distinction between Christian anti-Judaism and neo-pagan antisemitism and show that, at the heart of Christianity, hatred for Jews overwhelmingly formed the milieu of 20th-century Europe.

About the Author

Kevin P. Spicer, C.S.C., is Associate Professor of History at Stonehill College in Easton, Massachusetts. He is author of Resisting the Third Reich: The Catholic Clergy in Hitler's Berlin.

Reviews

"The twelve essays comprising this volume originated with a two-week workshop sponsored by the Center for Advanced Historical Studies at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in Washington DC. One of the book's chief aims, according to editor Kevin P. Spicer, is to challenge the "strict but misleading separation between Nazi 'racial antisemitism' and 'Christian antisemitism'" (p. ix). The contributors specifically address the role of antisemitism in the Christian response to Nazism, chronicling multiple points of overlap between Christian and Nazi antisemitism. The volume's weakness is that it contains a wide range of cross-disciplinary essays not overtly connected to each other. At the same time, the book's range and scope give it two great strengths: first, it includes work by historians and theologians, thereby representing both disciplinary perspectives; and second, it represents a wide range of Christian perspectives, and includes valuable analyses of Jewish views of Christian antisemitism. Organized into four parts, the book's first section addresses theological antisemitism. Essays by Thorstein Wagner, Anna Lysiak, Robert A. Krieg, and Donald Dietrich touch on a variety of expressions of antisemitism by priests, theologians, and other prominent religious figures in Denmark, Poland, Germany, and France. Ultimately, these authors show, Christian theology informed Nazi antisemitism in myriad ways that blended with national sentiment, and those bold Christian thinkers who sought to use their theology to resist Nazi anti-Jewishness found themselves bereft of the doctrinal tools to do so.Indeed, as Wagner's essay on the Danish Lutheran Church and the Jews shows, even Denmark's Lutheran clergy, who played a key role in the remarkable rescue of thousands of Danish Jews to Sweden in October 1943, were not free of antisemitism. Challenging the "narrative of heroic humanism" that has emerged as a result of the rescue, Wagner finds that Danish assistance to Jews was less rooted in a belief in religious pluralism and a regard for Jews than in a Danish nationalism constructed in opposition to Nazism and Nazi antisemitism. Further east, Christian thinkers in Poland and Germany deliberately misinterpreted Jewish texts, held fast to supersessionism (the idea that Christians replaced Jews in God's plan for salvation), maintained precritical interpretations of the Bible, and rejected the concept of religious freedom—positions that enabled the rapid spread of Nazi antisemitism. Even those who did think progressively about Christian-Jewish relations during the Nazi era, Dietrich shows, would not see their ideas come into wider acceptance until the Second Vatican Council. If those who sought to use Christian principles to resist Nazi antisemitism in the 1930s and 40s had difficulty doing so because of Christianity's inherent anti-Jewishness, it should come as no surprise that right-wing Catholic and Orthodox clergy were able to place antisemitism at the very center of their religious view of the world. The essays comprising part 2 of the book examining extreme right-wing Christian clergy in Germany and Romania are particularly good because of the authors' careful historicization of their subjects. Spicer, who recently published a separate full-length study of "brown priests"—enthusiastic clerical promoters of the Adolf Hitler regime—(Hitler's Priests: Catholic Clergy and National Socialism [2008]) focuses here on Dr. Philip Haeuser, one of the most well-known of the roughly two hundred such priests. Haeuser eagerly participated in the fashioning of a "Hybrid Catholic theology" that promoted the Nazi Party's agenda and fused traditional Catholic theological antisemitism with Nazi antisemitism. Church authorities in a position to condemn Haeuser's antisemitism chose instead to express concern over Christ's mission and the church in Germany, which they knew would be jeopardized if they condemned avid party supporters like Haeuser. Though the anti-Jewishness present in Christian traditions throughout Europe informed support for Nazi antisemitism, Romanian antisemitism, Paul Shapiro points out, had particularly deep roots in the Romanian Orthodox Church. Members of the notorious Iron Guard, the most powerful radical Right movement in Romania, drank deeply of Orthodox symbolism, poetry, speeches, and songs. Shapiro carefully details the historical antecedents within the Orthodox Church shaping the antisemitism of the Iron Guard. If the exigencies of the war prevented open discussion of antisemitism within Germany's Christian churches during the conflict, the immediate postwar period saw the first tenuous steps toward dialogue on the matter. The second half of the book, divided into two sections, "Postwar Jewish Encounters" and "Viewing Each Other," deals almost entirely with the Christian-Jewish relations during the postwar period. Supersessionism again is prominent in essays by Matthew D. Hockenos, who discusses the German Protestant Church and its Judenmission (mission to the Jews), and Elias H. Fullenbach, who focuses on German Catholic efforts to transcend Catholic antisemitism in the postwar years. The view that Jews needed converting to Christianity persisted (officially) until the issuance of the Berlin-Weissensee statement in 1950 by the German Protestant churches, which maintained some elements of missionary thinking, but rejected supersessionism. Fullenbach's essay focuses on the work of Karl Thieme, Gertrud Luckner, and the Frieburg Circle, whose members sought to illuminate, among other things, how the view of Jews as potential converts was antisemitic. Their work, controversial in the immediate postwar period, laid the groundwork for the issuance of Nostra Aetate in 1965, which acknowledged the "spiritual patrimony" between Jews and Christians and rejected the idea of Jewish guilt in the death of Christ. Gershon Greenberg, the author of one of this volume's final essays, cogently argues that "attitudes and views should be studied in terms of the dialectical relationship that existed during the war, interrelating Judaism and Christianity in terms of each other's perceptions; their separate study creates an independence and an active-passive dichotomy that did not exist historically" (p. 264). Greenberg focuses on Orthodox Jewish responses to Holocaust Christianity, while Suzanne Brown-Fleming examines the largely unsuccessful efforts of American Rabbi Philip Bernstein to persuade a series of Catholic prelates to renounce antisemitism in several forms. The book's final essay by Richard Steigmann-Gall begins with a discussion of the controversies surrounding Dabru Emet, the statement on Christians and Christianity issued in 2000 under the signature of more than 170 rabbis and Jewish scholars. His essay, however, is more of an analysis of the writings and speeches of several prominent Nazi ideologues, including Joseph Goebbels and Hitler. Steigmann-Gall, who has authored a full-length study of Nazi conceptions of Christianity (The Holy Reich: Nazi Conceptions of Christianity [2004]), finds that "the same antisemitism that is usually regarded as a function of racialism was for many Nazis conceived within a Christian frame of reference" (p. 304). This final disquieting essay of the volume, in concluding that antisemitism was for key Nazi figures a function of Christianity rather than racialism, reveals the least ambivalence concerning the relationship between Christian and Nazi antisemitism—for Steigmann-Gall's subjects, Nazi antisemitism was forged within a Christian matrix. This volume's inclusion of essays on several different Christian traditions, as well as the Jewish perspective on Christian antisemitism make it especially valuable for understanding varieties of Christian antisemitism and ultimately, the practice and consequences of exclusionary thinking in general. In bringing a range of theological and historical perspectives to bear on the question of Christian and Nazi antisemitism, the book broadens our view on the question, and is of great value to historians and theologians alike."—Maria Mazzenga, Catholic University of America, H-Catholic, H-Net, January, 2009

"[An] excellent collection . . . ."—EUGENE J. FISHER, Secretariat for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs

(Associate Director Emeritus)

United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, CATHOLIC HISTORICAL REVIEW, Vol. 94, 4 October 2008

". . . Spicer's anthology convinces by its breadth and depth and is indispensable for all scholars in the field.3. 2008"—Katharina von Kellenbach, St. Mary's College of Maryland

". . . sheds light on and offers steps to overcome the locked-in conflict between Jews and Christians along the antisemitic path from Calvary to Auschwitz and beyond.Vol. 27, No. 1 Fall 2008"—Zev Garber, Los Angeles Valley Collegeand American Jewish University

". . . a well packed collection of twelve articles on the ambivalence of the Christian Church toward the Holocaust and antisemitism. The collection is introduced by Kevin P. Spicer and Father John T. Pawlikowski, both well-known authors on the subject. Each article is followed with extensive endnotes, and the editorial work, by both Spicer and the publisher, is superb. The flow of thought is easy to follow.Vol 50, 3 Summer 2008"—JOHN JOVAN MARKOVIC, ANDREWS UNIVERSITY

"[An] excellent collection . . . .Vol. 94, 4 October 2008"—EUGENE J. FISHER, Secretariat for Ecumenical and Interreligious Affairs(Associate Director Emeritus)United States Co

"This volume's inclusion of essays on several different Christian traditions, as well as the Jewish perspective on Christian antisemitism make it especially valuable for understanding varieties of Christian antisemitism and ultimately, the practice and consequences of exclusionary thinking in general. In bringing a range of theological and historical perspectives to bear on the question of Christian and Nazi antisemitism, the book broadens our view on the question, and is of great value to historians and theologians alike.January 2009"—Maria Mazzenga, Catholic University of America

"[This] book displays the sort of thematic and methodological diversity one might expect from a project designed to foster dialogue across disciplinary lines by historians and theologians.23.1 Winter 2009"—HOLOCAUST aND GENOCIDE STUDIES
Indiana University Press

9780253348739 : antisemitism-christian-ambivalence-and-the-holocaust-spicer
Hardback
360 Pages
$32.00 USD

Other Titles by Kevin P. Spicer

The Evil That Surrounds Us

edited by Kevin P. Spicer, Martina Cucchiara
Sep 2017 - Indiana University Press
$70.00 USD - Hardback
$25.00 USD - Paperback / softback

Other Titles in HISTORY / Europe / General

Studies in Eighteenth-Century Culture, Volume 53

edited by David A. Brewer and Crystal B. Lake
Apr 2024 - Johns Hopkins University Press
$50.00 USD - Hardback

Monty and the Canadian Army

John A. English
Oct 2023 - University of Toronto Press
$42.95 USD - Hardback
$29.95 USD - Paperback / softback

Women Doctors in Weimar and Nazi Germany

Melissa Kravetz
Sep 2023 - University of Toronto Press
$39.95 USD - Paperback / softback
$85.00 USD - Hardback

Other Titles in European history

The Habsburg Garrison Complex in Trebinje

Cathie Carmichael
Sep 2024 - Central European University Press
$79.00 USD - Hardback

Jewishness and Beyond

Miklós Konrád. Translated by Jason Vincz and the author.
Aug 2024 - Indiana University Press
$90.00 USD - Hardback
$50.00 USD - Paperback / softback

Biopower in Putin's Russia

Andrey Makarychev, Sergei Medvedev
Jul 2024 - Central European University Press
$58.00 USD - Hardback